Wednesday, September 15, 2010

What's all this Phd stuff anyhow ?

There are a whole lot of misconceptions about folks who do a Phd, and about the process of doing it . Some of these misconceptions are funny , some downright weird. There are some who label aspiring phds as' mad' claiming that they've gone crazy about 'technical stuff' and they dont really belong in this world. Some others believe that a phd is a journey of prolonged depression that some 'mad' ( maybe this explains the earlier 'mad' bit ) people willingly undertake, so that they have enough things to crib about for the rest of their lives.

A lab-mate of mine recently asked me quite seriously ' How can you be smiling most of the time being a phd student?' ! His question left me laughing of course . These are my early days in phd, and my worst days ( and hopefully also the best :-) are yet to come. But I've done enough non-technical research to figure out that phd need not necessarily be a journey of misery. Its best treated as a project at workplace, where some things work and many don't. Intelligence matters, but not as much as perseverence. And perhaps, the most important thing to remember is that its no use reinventing the wheel .

Many students treat phd to be a (m)ad-venture where the advisor has you playing treasure hunt with no clues, and a hard deadline. I'm lucky to have a great advisor, and that simplifies things greatly. I think students might feel luckier if they realised that the advisor is actually doing them a great favour by poking holes in their arguments, and pointing out flaws before the student's stupidity is advertised to the world at large.

Perhaps, the most liberating thought is that while doing a phd does take a certain amount of madness, ( just like any other passionate endeavour does) 'balanced madness' is possible. I believe its possible to work an average of 8 hours a day , five or at most six days a week, and finish it in good time. Its possible ( and I believe, essential ) to have a life outside of work. Its good to intersperse one's worries about work, with worries about other things :-)

And most importantly, I think phd also offers an opportunity for great personal growth, if we are willing to recognize it. We can find the time to pursue other interests and work on them, if we so wish. Many of my musical ideas have emerged while day-dreaming; staring at the lush green lawns in the beautiful IISc campus, a setting that a cubicle can never hope to replicate, in terms of the inspiration it offers.

And to those who aren't doing a phd ( and treat phds with suspicion :-) - I' d like to say that folks who've done phds aren't really different . Some might turn out to be pedantic, some others might be snobs, but a good number are just like anyone else. It just so happens that they get paid little for working very hard. So they better be very interested in their work, for there is no other real motivation to do it :-)

So , here are my parting words to myself , and anyone else who might want to take it - 'Its better to travel well than to arrive' ( Buddha ) . So enjoy the journey !

15 comments:

Lalit Patnaik said...

A very well articulated post. I enjoyed reading it, possibly because I too am doing a PhD and am certainly enjoying it :-)

Karthik said...

Thanks for the generous comment Lalit !

Rafiki said...

Hey Karthik, thanks for dropping by my blog. I love what you say here abt PhD. I have been called Permanently Head Damaged for wanting to pursue a PhD. :)

And yes PhD is surely more about perseverance than it is about intelligence.

You are lucky to be doing your PhD in IISc in namma Bengaluru.

Karthik said...

Ha ha ! :-) I haven't heard the 'Permanent head damage' joke before !:-) Yes, its nice to be doing it in IISc!

Sujit Kumar Chakrabarti said...

HI Karthik, I must say "Great Going!" Many of the wisdoms you shared here were hard to come to me. I realised quite late that it's OK to take a break. I knew the constructive criticism bit, but took time to internalise it. My bit of advice to newcomers:
- Do your homework before joining.
- Treat it as a job. Be sincere, that's all. To take it tooooo seriously.
- Do other things, but only after ascertaining that you are spending a certain amount of regular effort in your research.

I can't think of anything more off my head.

Again! Great going Karthik.

PS: ...it's also OK for PhD students to take a break; and while doing so, it's very good to visit (or at least to call up) their old friends! ;)

Pritesh said...

Hahaha, Sujit summed it all up nicely. And a great post Karthik. I so totally agree that PhD needn't be a be all and end all (just like anything else you do). It sure takes a whole lot of passion to finish this endeavour and hence, the usual sense of madness associated with it. But then, anything you do with passion does need a certain amount of madness to finish it to one's satisfaction. Couldn't help remembering one particular incident though. A colleague of mine (long time ago) was into 3rd year of his PhD. Try as hard as he may, his parents just didn't grasp what he was doing. One day, his parents (very sympathetically) told him, "See if you've failed in your course, even if many times, it's ok. Tell us. We won't scold you. Come back home, no need to go on studying for a course you can't pass". :D So, you see, misconceptions abound! :-)

Karthik said...

Thanks Sujit ! Actually many of these learnings came from mistakes I made it work :-) So having already made some, I hope I will only make new mistakes during the phd :-) Thanks for your additional points ! Ya man, got the point :-) Will call you tomorrow ;-)

@Pritesh - Ha ha !!! That is next level misconeption !:-) first time I'm hearing of this one !!

Pritesh said...

@ Karthik: I do feel bad for the parents though. Poor things, try as hard as they may, research will probably not make sense to them! My own Dad kept asking me right till the end of my PhD: Beta, padhai kaisi chal rahi hai? :D

Shantanu Prabhudesai said...

Karthik, very inspiring post! It makes me think hard...

Karthik said...

Thanks Shantanu ! glad you liked it.

Neeraja said...

Very well put! :) I too am in the throes of slogging out my PhD, so your thoughts resonated with mine perfectly! As one of my profs used to say, the "P" in PhD stands for perseverance. If you ask me it's passion; that's what really drives me.

Btw, I enjoy your witty writing - especially your puns :). And, I love Wodehouse too!

Karthik said...

Neeraja,
Thanks for you generous comments:-)Its hard to stay passionate all the time when there are no results, so I guess thats where perseverence comes in ! ;-)
All the best for your Phd !! oh cool ! Wodehouse is simply amazing!

Anonymous said...

Great post, I am almost 100% in agreement with you

Meens said...

"A lab-mate of mine recently asked me quite seriously ' How can you be smiling most of the time being a phd student?' ! His question left me laughing of course" - enjoyed this line very much :)

Great post to read for PhD and non-PhD folks :) Great attitude :) All the very best, Karthik.

Karthik said...

Ya that was a funny question from the labmate !:-) Thanks a lot for your wishes Meenakshi :-)