Saturday, October 01, 2005

For the Love of Science


I was meant to be a physicist. I discovered this when I was 14. We had an amazing Physics teacher that year. For one, she did not dictate notes ; meaning she knew and had enough things to say for the entire duration of the lecture. Someone(don't recall who:) once said " A good teacher is one who does not cover the subject but uncovers it for the students ". The Physics lectures were gripping,much like a murder mystery being solved. I recall being upset when she once cancelled a class due to other commitments. Ever since, almost all lecture cancellations have only brought joy to me.


All the formulae seemed intuitively obvious and nature seemed to behave just the way I had imagined. More importantly, I was somehow exposed to the culture of Physics. I read about Feynman,Weisskopf,Raman, Chadrashekar ... and I was inspired.


The next year, however , I was disillusioned.We had to give the 'board exams' that year. My bio-gas plants were not drawn neatly enough and there were four advantages of solar panels while I had laid down only three. We were expected to practise writing answers to 'important questions'.


I am now an Electronics engineer, doing my masters at IISc. I have no regrets.I love electronics and read popular science books whenever I get a chance. But , there are probably millions who lose their enthusiasm along the way.Some of these might even be potential Nobel Laureates.


What can we do about this?. Firstly , in my opinion teachers ought to be paid ten times more. Each teacher has in her power, the ability to influence hundreds of students in her career. In some sense it is the teachers who shape each new generation. They play a very important role and naturally ought to be paid more. This would automatically attract the best teachers.


The students should be introduced to the culture of the subject. Anyone who's a Linux fan would know exactly what I mean. Learning science without knowing the best scientists is like learning to play cricket in India without being aware of the existence of Sachin Tendulkar. Kids develop an interest in sports after watching these guys in action. While they may not be able to do it themselves, they recognise and appreciate the finer nuances of the game. That's what we need to do. Instill an interest and appreciation for the subject before delving into the details. Students need to be told the relevance of science. Telling them that regular study will fetch them good marks in the exams will cause more harm than good.


I recently came across a book by Freeman Dyson(he's a Professor Of Physics at the Institute of Advanced Study,Princeton) titled "Disturbing the Universe". There are two categories of people who ought to read this book : Those who are scientists and those who aren't." As a reviewer put it, he is a "scientist possessed with a rare sensitivity". Read this book if you can get hold of it. You will be pleasantly surrpised .

9 comments:

Kunal said...

wish I could buy that book.... but as of now, I'm broke.

Nice post. Hope you are doing fine... haven't heard from you lately (again :-) ;-) ) anyways, keep up the great posts. cheers!

karthik said...

Superb writeup there pran.....

btw, who is this amazing physics teacher??

My bio-gas plants were not drawn neatly enough and there were four advantages of solar panels while I had laid down only three

:-) :-)

Karthik said...

The amazing teacher - Mahalakshmi Vijaychand(princi).She was the right kind of teacher for me .

Kunal said...

Hey actually, a little thought made me feel the same about engineering too. I mean there are hardly any engineers who understand the culture of their profession.
In addition, when it comes to an engineer, I'd say that these are the guys who should understand the culture of science too (most comp. sci. guys are given a break here ;-) )
Would do wonders to the quality of engineering graduates.

But I'll never live to see that day.

Kunal said...

and yes, my 'teachers' for physics would be Resnick & Halliday + Richard Feynman

fuse me said...

Really, there is a dirth of the culture of the profession people follow, same lies with teachers too who are supposed to inculcate this culture, now who teaches them ? :-)

fuse me said...

Really, there is a dirth of the culture of the profession people follow, same lies with teachers too who are supposed to inculcate this culture, now who teaches them ? :-)

Karthik said...

Who teaches the teachers abt culture ?interesting question.but i think if they are paid more,the ones who know will take to teaching.
i will surely end up teaching later.(irrespective of the pay:)

Anonymous said...

What a great web log. I spend hours on the net reading blogs, about tons of various subjects. I have to first of all give praise to whoever created your theme and second of all to you for writing what i can only describe as an fabulous article. I honestly believe there is a skill to writing articles that only very few posses and honestly you got it. The combining of demonstrative and upper-class content is by all odds super rare with the astronomic amount of blogs on the cyberspace.